95-Unit Apartment Building Proposed at Former Essex House Site on Northfield Avenue in West Orange

A developer wants to turn the shuttered Essex House restaurant property at 525 Northfield Avenue in West Orange into a four-story building with about 100 apartments over ground-floor commercial space. The proposal was carried from the August Planning Board meeting to September, and as of this update the board has still not taken a final vote: the application is working through completeness reviews while the developer refines details. Here is what the project would mean for homeowners, tenants, and anyone watching the Northfield Avenue corridor.

---

What is being proposed?

The plan, filed as application PB-25-11 by 525 Northfield Ave LLC, would redevelop the site where the Essex House restaurant long operated. The details on the table include:

• A four-story mixed-use building on the roughly 2.2-acre parcel
• About 1,200 square feet of commercial space on the ground floor
• Roughly 95 to 104 residential units across the upper floors, depending on the latest revision
• About a fifth of the units set aside as affordable, consistent with the township's Fair Share plan, which lists the site for around 12 affordable units
• Approximately 165 off-street parking spaces, including lower-level garage parking
• The property is zoned B-2 General Business along a busy commercial avenue

The application seeks preliminary and final major site plan approval along with variances. As of the September Planning Board meeting, the township has not granted approval, the application has been marked incomplete at recent completeness reviews, and the building is not being demolished yet.

---

Why the Essex House history matters here

The Essex House is more than just any restaurant building to a lot of locals. It has been part of the neighborhood for decades, and West Orange officials have warned the developer that demolishing it could face a fight. That history matters for a few reasons:

• Historic character. Towns that protect longtime landmarks tend to keep the neighborhood feel that buyers move here for, even as they add housing.
• Timeline. A contested demolition can stretch the approval process, so this project may take longer than a typical infill build.
• Uncertainty for neighbors. When a well-known local property sits in limbo, it can raise questions for nearby sellers and buyers about what comes next.

---

How this fits the market

West Orange, like most of Essex County, has a serious housing shortage, and the town is weighing multiple ways to add supply. A building of roughly 100 units on a commercial avenue is meaningful but modest. The affordable units would also nudge West Orange toward its state housing obligation, which matters because the township is juggling a handful of builder's remedy lawsuits over that same obligation.

For buyers, more rental supply on a busy commercial street mostly supports the rental market rather than disrupting established neighborhoods. For homeowners nearby, the biggest issues to watch are parking, construction traffic, and what gets approved for the historic building itself.

---

What to watch next

The September Planning Board meeting came and went without a final vote. The application is still in the completeness phase, which means the board has not yet even reached the substance of the proposal. The two things I would track from here are whether the applicant clears completeness so the board can schedule a hearing on the merits, and whether the historic Essex House demolition becomes a point of contention. If either of those drags out, this is a project that could take a while, so read any "coming soon" timing with that in mind.

---

The bottom line

This is a proposal, not an approval yet. It would add roughly 100 apartments and a small commercial space on an established commercial avenue, with about a fifth of the units affordable. It also puts a beloved local restaurant site in question, and as of September the application is still working through completeness review. For homeowners, the near-term impact is likely to be modest. For buyers and renters, it is another sign of a town actively working through how, and where, to add housing.

If you are weighing a move to West Orange and wondering what all of this means for prices or the neighborhood, I am happy to talk through it. No pressure, just honest local guidance.