Bloomfield vs. West Orange vs. Montclair vs. South Orange
Which town is right for you? A side-by-side comparison of Essex County's most popular towns for NYC relocators - prices, commutes, walkability, and what your budget actually gets you.
TL;DR
Four towns. Three price tiers. All within 35–55 minutes of Midtown Manhattan. Each has a distinct personality and market - here's how they stack up.
Side-by-Side Comparison
Every town in Essex County offers something different. Here's how the four most popular options for NYC relocators compare.
Source: Redfin 07003, Redfin 07052, Redfin Montclair, and Redfin 07079 housing market pages, plus Gemhaus 07052 (sale-to-list), accessed October 12, 2026. Figures reflect public market data as reported by each source and change frequently.
Bloomfield
~$619K
Tree-lined streets, direct Montclair-Boonton rail to Penn, two county parks (Brookdale 121 ac, Watsessing ~69 ac)
Bloomfield Station · NJ Transit Montclair-Boonton Line · ~40 min to Penn Station
Moderate - Walk Score 70; Bloomfield Center has shops and restaurants, car helpful elsewhere
$12,381 avg residential bill (TY 2025) · 2.391 effective rate
~106% of asking (hot homes ~13% over) · ~60 days on market (Redfin)
Direct 40-min rail to Penn, median ~$619K, two county parks in town
West Orange
~$656K
Spacious lots, mix of colonials and split-levels, South Mountain Reservation access
No direct train - bus service to NJ Transit, ~45–55 min to Midtown by bus + PATH or via neighboring towns
Lower - Walk Score 56; car-dependent, but close to Montclair and South Orange dining/shopping
$16,168 avg residential bill (TY 2025) · 3.080 effective rate
~107% of asking (Sept snapshot 108.1%) · ~23 days on market
2,110-acre South Mountain Reservation; jitney shuttle + bus to rail; varied lot sizes
Montclair
~$1.3M
Walkable downtown (Walk Score 80, Bloomfield Ave 94-99), six rail stations, historic homes
Multiple stations (Montclair State, Mountain Station, Bay Street, etc.) · Midtown Direct ~35–40 min
High - downtown shops, restaurants, farmers market, theaters all walkable
$22,489 avg residential bill (TY 2025) · 2.160 effective rate
~111-121% of asking (07042 vs city-wide) · ~17-41 days on market
Walk Score 80; six Montclair-Boonton Line stations; 121-acre Brookdale Park
South Orange
~$1.2M
Walkable village center (Walk Score 79), Seton Hall University, direct Midtown Direct rail
South Orange Station · NJ Transit Midtown Direct · ~40 min to Penn Station
High - village center has shops, restaurants, cinema
$22,720 avg residential bill (TY 2025) · 2.469 effective rate
~115% of asking (hot homes ~29% over) · ~12-15 days on market
Walk Score 79; South Orange Station ~40 min to Penn; Meadowland Park ~45 ac
Bloomfield
~$619K
Bloomfield
~$619K
Tree-lined streets, direct Montclair-Boonton rail to Penn, two county parks (Brookdale 121 ac, Watsessing ~69 ac)
Bloomfield Station · NJ Transit Montclair-Boonton Line · ~40 min to Penn Station
Moderate - Walk Score 70; Bloomfield Center has shops and restaurants, car helpful elsewhere
$12,381 avg residential bill (TY 2025) · 2.391 effective rate
~106% of asking (hot homes ~13% over) · ~60 days on market (Redfin)
Direct 40-min rail to Penn, median ~$619K, two county parks in town
West Orange
~$656K
West Orange
~$656K
Spacious lots, mix of colonials and split-levels, South Mountain Reservation access
No direct train - bus service to NJ Transit, ~45–55 min to Midtown by bus + PATH or via neighboring towns
Lower - Walk Score 56; car-dependent, but close to Montclair and South Orange dining/shopping
$16,168 avg residential bill (TY 2025) · 3.080 effective rate
~107% of asking (Sept snapshot 108.1%) · ~23 days on market
2,110-acre South Mountain Reservation; jitney shuttle + bus to rail; varied lot sizes
Montclair
~$1.3M
Montclair
~$1.3M
Walkable downtown (Walk Score 80, Bloomfield Ave 94-99), six rail stations, historic homes
Multiple stations (Montclair State, Mountain Station, Bay Street, etc.) · Midtown Direct ~35–40 min
High - downtown shops, restaurants, farmers market, theaters all walkable
$22,489 avg residential bill (TY 2025) · 2.160 effective rate
~111-121% of asking (07042 vs city-wide) · ~17-41 days on market
Walk Score 80; six Montclair-Boonton Line stations; 121-acre Brookdale Park
South Orange
~$1.2M
South Orange
~$1.2M
Walkable village center (Walk Score 79), Seton Hall University, direct Midtown Direct rail
South Orange Station · NJ Transit Midtown Direct · ~40 min to Penn Station
High - village center has shops, restaurants, cinema
$22,720 avg residential bill (TY 2025) · 2.469 effective rate
~115% of asking (hot homes ~29% over) · ~12-15 days on market
Walk Score 79; South Orange Station ~40 min to Penn; Meadowland Park ~45 ac
What $600K Gets You
3-bed colonial, 1,400–1,800 sq ft, tree-lined street
3-bed split-level, 1,500–2,000 sq ft, larger lot
Limited - mostly condos or fixer-uppers at this price
Limited - condos or smaller homes
What $1M Gets You
Top of market - renovated colonial, 2,000+ sq ft
Renovated colonial or split, 2,200+ sq ft, premium lot
3–4 bed colonial, 1,800–2,200 sq ft, good condition
3–4 bed colonial, 1,800–2,400 sq ft, walkable to village
Essex County Property Tax Comparison
Average residential property tax bills and effective (equalized) tax rates for the ten Essex County towns covered on this site, from the NJ Division of Taxation's MOD IV Average Residential Statistics report and 2025 General Tax Rates table, Tax Year 2025. Each figure is cross-checked against a second source; your own bill depends on the assessed value of the specific home.
| Town | Avg Residential Tax Bill | Effective Rate (per $100) | Tax Year |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bloomfield | $12,381 | 2.391 | Tax Year 2025 |
| Cedar Grove | $12,460 | 1.943 | Tax Year 2025 |
| Glen Ridge | $23,676 | 2.257 | Tax Year 2025 |
| Livingston | $18,469 | 1.882 | Tax Year 2025 |
| Maplewood | $19,380 | 2.434 | Tax Year 2025 |
| Montclair | $22,489 | 2.160 | Tax Year 2025 |
| Nutley | $13,316 | 2.426 | Tax Year 2025 |
| Roseland | $11,917 | 1.817 | Tax Year 2025 |
| South Orange | $22,720 | 2.469 | Tax Year 2025 |
| West Orange | $16,168 | 3.080 | Tax Year 2025 |
Effective rates for Cranford, Summit, and Westfield (Union County) and Madison (Morris County) are on those towns' own guide pages.
Sources
- NJ Division of Taxation, MOD IV Average Residential Statistics, Tax Year 2025 (average residential tax bills)
- NJ Division of Taxation, 2025 General Tax Rates (effective rates per $100 of equalized value)
- Patch, Essex County Ranked By Property Taxes (Tax Year 2025) (cross-check: county town-by-town list)
- nj.com, The 30 N.J. towns with the highest municipal tax bills (cross-check: Maplewood, Montclair)
The state republishes these tables annually; cross-check current-year figures before relying on them, and ask Sorelle for a bill estimate on any specific home.
Key Takeaways
Every town in Essex County has something different to offer. The right one depends on your budget, commute preferences, and lifestyle.
Homes in all four towns routinely sell above asking price - full mortgage pre-approval is essential to compete.
Get Your Personalized Town Comparison
These tables give you the broad picture. For a free, personalized market analysis, Sorelle will run your actual budget, commute, and must-haves against the towns you're considering, and walk you through the pros and cons. No pressure.
What you'll get back:
- Real comparable sales in your target towns
- A realistic budget including property taxes
- Commute options that fit your schedule
- A clear recommendation on which towns to shortlist
Get Your Personalized Numbers
Tell Sorelle a little about your search and she'll come back with personalized numbers for the towns that fit your budget and lifestyle.
More Free Tools
Get the Full Cheat Sheet as a Free PDF
Includes detailed tax breakdowns, school resources, commute comparisons, and a printable checklist for your town search.
Inside the PDF:
- Detailed property tax breakdowns by town
- School ratings and resources
- Commute time comparisons (train, bus, car)
- Walkability scores and highlights
- Printable town search checklist
- What your budget gets you at every price point
Have questions about which town fits your needs? Let's talk.
Download the Free Cheat Sheet
Enter your name and email to get the full PDF delivered to your inbox.
Not sure which town fits your life?
I'll walk you through the pros and cons of each one based on your budget, commute, and lifestyle. No pressure - just honest advice.