Bloomfield vs. West Orange vs. Montclair vs. South Orange
Which town is right for you? A side-by-side comparison of Essex County's most popular towns for NYC relocators – prices, commutes, walkability, and what your budget actually gets you.
TL;DR
Four towns. Three price tiers. All within 35–55 minutes of Midtown Manhattan. Each has a distinct personality and market – here's how they stack up.
Side-by-Side Comparison
Every town in Essex County offers something different. Here's how the four most popular options for NYC relocators compare.
Bloomfield
$590K–$600K
Quiet, suburban, diverse, family-oriented neighborhoods with tree-lined streets
Bloomfield Station · NJ Transit Montclair-Boonton Line · ~40 min to Penn Station
Moderate – Bloomfield Center has shops and restaurants, car helpful elsewhere
Lower end for Essex County
~104% of asking · ~17 days on market
First-time buyers, NYC renters priced out of Brooklyn/Hoboken, value seekers
West Orange
~$695K
Suburban, spacious lots, mix of colonials and split-levels, South Mountain Reservation access
No direct train – bus service to NJ Transit, ~45–55 min to Midtown by bus + PATH or via neighboring towns
Lower – car-dependent, but close to Montclair and South Orange dining/shopping
Moderate
~104% of asking · ~21 days on market
Move-up buyers wanting space and nature, commuters who don't mind driving to the train
Montclair
$1.2M–$1.4M
Artsy, walkable downtown, diverse restaurants, historic homes, vibrant community
Multiple stations (Montclair State, Mountain Station, Bay Street, etc.) · Midtown Direct ~35–40 min
High – downtown shops, restaurants, farmers market, theaters all walkable
Higher end, but services and schools reflect it
~126% of asking · ~16 days on market – extremely competitive
Move-up buyers, families wanting walkable downtown + direct train, higher-income relocators
South Orange
$985K–$1.1M
College town feel (Seton Hall), walkable village center, diverse, strong community
South Orange Station · NJ Transit Midtown Direct · ~40 min to Penn Station
High – village center has shops, restaurants, cinema
Moderate to high
~109% of asking · ~13 days on market
Move-up buyers wanting Montclair vibes at a slightly lower price point, commuters
Bloomfield
$590K–$600K
Bloomfield
$590K–$600K
Quiet, suburban, diverse, family-oriented neighborhoods with tree-lined streets
Bloomfield Station · NJ Transit Montclair-Boonton Line · ~40 min to Penn Station
Moderate – Bloomfield Center has shops and restaurants, car helpful elsewhere
Lower end for Essex County
~104% of asking · ~17 days on market
First-time buyers, NYC renters priced out of Brooklyn/Hoboken, value seekers
West Orange
~$695K
West Orange
~$695K
Suburban, spacious lots, mix of colonials and split-levels, South Mountain Reservation access
No direct train – bus service to NJ Transit, ~45–55 min to Midtown by bus + PATH or via neighboring towns
Lower – car-dependent, but close to Montclair and South Orange dining/shopping
Moderate
~104% of asking · ~21 days on market
Move-up buyers wanting space and nature, commuters who don't mind driving to the train
Montclair
$1.2M–$1.4M
Montclair
$1.2M–$1.4M
Artsy, walkable downtown, diverse restaurants, historic homes, vibrant community
Multiple stations (Montclair State, Mountain Station, Bay Street, etc.) · Midtown Direct ~35–40 min
High – downtown shops, restaurants, farmers market, theaters all walkable
Higher end, but services and schools reflect it
~126% of asking · ~16 days on market – extremely competitive
Move-up buyers, families wanting walkable downtown + direct train, higher-income relocators
South Orange
$985K–$1.1M
South Orange
$985K–$1.1M
College town feel (Seton Hall), walkable village center, diverse, strong community
South Orange Station · NJ Transit Midtown Direct · ~40 min to Penn Station
High – village center has shops, restaurants, cinema
Moderate to high
~109% of asking · ~13 days on market
Move-up buyers wanting Montclair vibes at a slightly lower price point, commuters
What $600K Gets You
3-bed colonial, 1,400–1,800 sq ft, tree-lined street
3-bed split-level, 1,500–2,000 sq ft, larger lot
Limited – mostly condos or fixer-uppers at this price
Limited – condos or smaller homes
What $1M Gets You
Top of market – renovated colonial, 2,000+ sq ft
Renovated colonial or split, 2,200+ sq ft, premium lot
3–4 bed colonial, 1,800–2,200 sq ft, good condition
3–4 bed colonial, 1,800–2,400 sq ft, walkable to village
Key Takeaways
Every town in Essex County has something different to offer. The right one depends on your budget, commute preferences, and lifestyle.
Homes in all four towns routinely sell above asking price – full mortgage pre-approval is essential to compete.
Get the Full Cheat Sheet as a Free PDF
Includes detailed tax breakdowns, school resources, commute comparisons, and a printable checklist for your town search.
Inside the PDF:
- Detailed property tax breakdowns by town
- School ratings and resources
- Commute time comparisons (train, bus, car)
- Walkability scores and highlights
- Printable town search checklist
- What your budget gets you at every price point
Have questions about which town fits your needs? Let's talk.
Download the Free Cheat Sheet
Enter your name and email to get the full PDF delivered to your inbox.
Not sure which town fits your life?
I'll walk you through the pros and cons of each one based on your budget, commute, and lifestyle. No pressure – just honest advice.