West Orange Approves the Daughters of Israel Builder's Remedy Settlement: What the Deal Means

West Orange's Town Council unanimously approved a settlement agreement on Tuesday, October 13, 2026, ending the township's long-running builder's remedy lawsuit with Daughters of Israel, the nonprofit that operates a skilled-nursing campus at 1155 Pleasant Valley Way. The deal clears the way for a continuing care retirement community on the roughly 18-acre site and resolves one of the six builder's remedy lawsuits pressing West Orange over its overdue housing plan. Here is what the approved settlement means for homeowners, buyers, and anyone watching how this town adds housing.

---

The lawsuit behind the settlement

Daughters of Israel sued West Orange after the Zoning Board denied its June 2023 application to redevelop its skilled-nursing campus, in the case Daughters of Israel, Inc. v. Zoning Board of Adjustment of the Township of West Orange (Docket No. ESX-L-4045-23, Application No. ZB-21-21). The property, Block 171, Lot 12, sits in an R-2 residential zone on Pleasant Valley Way.

Builder's remedy lawsuits let a developer bypass local zoning when a town has not met its state affordable housing obligation, as long as the project includes affordable units. West Orange missed the June 30, 2025 deadline for its Fourth-Round Housing Element and Fair Share Plan, and Daughters of Israel is one of six lawsuits that followed. A settlement is how a town and a developer agree on what gets built without leaving the outcome to a judge.

---

What the approved settlement allows

The settlement, approved after a special council session on October 7 reviewed the pending litigation, lets Daughters of Israel build a continuing care retirement community on its campus at 1155 Pleasant Valley Way (Block 171, Lot 12). Publicized parameters for the project call for a continuing care community with independent living, assisted living, and skilled-nursing components, with roughly 311 total residential units including a minimum of 41 affordable beds, revised down from an earlier proposal of 326. Township officials said a future ordinance will spell out the zoning specifics, and the town's tree and steep-slope rules will apply to the site.

For neighbors, the practical read is that this is not a market-rate apartment tower. A continuing care community is a senior-living campus with a care component, the kind of use that fits the site's existing character and brings residents who need services rather than a large new student or commuter population.

---

What it means for homeowners and buyers

• One lawsuit resolved, five to go. The settlement takes one of six builder's remedy cases off the table, but the township still faces the others, including the contested West Essex Highlands project on the Watchung Mountains. The fight over where West Orange adds housing is not over.
• Affordable units count toward the town's obligation. The 41-plus affordable beds in the approved community help West Orange make progress on its state housing requirement, which is the pressure driving all of these lawsuits.
• Certainty beats litigation. For homeowners, a negotiated settlement is generally easier to live with than a court-imposed development, because the town gets a say in height, density, and design. That predictability matters for property values.
• Fair share plan still matters. West Orange's own housing plan, still moving through adoption, is the town's strongest defense against the remaining lawsuits. Watch for that plan and the fate of the other five cases.

---

How this fits West Orange's housing story

West Orange is at the center of Essex County's affordable housing pressure. Between the builder's remedy lawsuits, the 425-unit complex approved on Executive Drive, the 142-unit project on Pleasant Valley Way, and the long fight over the Watchung Mountains, the town is juggling more development proposals than most of its neighbors. The common thread is a housing obligation the town missed, and the result is that developers are choosing the sites. A settlement like this one gives the town a measure of control back, which is why the council spent a special session reviewing it before the formal vote.

---

What to watch next

With the settlement approved, the next steps are the ordinance that will spell out the zoning for the site, then site plan review, which is where neighbors get their next chance to weigh in on building height, unit count, and the affordable set-aside. Track the other five builder's remedy cases and the adoption of West Orange's Fair Share housing plan too, because those two threads will shape where the next round of development lands.

---

The bottom line

The approved settlement ends one of West Orange's six builder's remedy lawsuits and brings a continuing care retirement community to Pleasant Valley Way, with a meaningful affordable set-aside. It is a step toward control for the township, but not the end of the housing fight. For homeowners, the takeaway is that development pressure on West Orange is real and ongoing, and for buyers, it is a reminder that the town's housing plan is one of the most important things to understand before you choose a neighborhood.

If you are buying or selling in West Orange and want to understand how the housing plan and these lawsuits could affect your street or your market, I am happy to walk you through it. No pressure, just honest local guidance.